Road signs leading to some of the now gone Borscht Belt hotels
This summer, the Borscht Belt Historical Marker Project will add another chapter to its journey with the installation of five new markers at key locations in the Catskills.
Each town or village on the trail is associated with a celebrated era that holds a significant place in American Jewish history.
A Look Back at the Borscht Belt Heyday
From the 1920s to the 1970s, the Borscht Belt (named for the beloved Eastern European beet soup) thrived. Boasting an impressive 500 hotels and resorts, 50,000 bungalows, and countless rooming houses, the Catskills offered a welcoming haven for generations of predominantly Eastern European Jews.
With its delicious ethnic cuisine, top-notch entertainment, and convenient proximity to New York City, the Borscht Belt also offered a sense of belonging and acceptance, an antidote to the rampant anti-Semitism in the hospitality industry at that time.
Preserving Jewish Heritage
Marisa Scheinfeld leads this ambitious project, which is generously supported by the Jewish American Society for Historic Preservation. This non-profit volunteer organization identifies and recognizes significant sites in American Jewish history.
The project's initial four markers were installed in 2023, in Monticello, Mountain Dale, Swan Lake, and Fallsburg. This summer's expansion brings markers to South Fallsburg, Kiamesha, Hurleyville, Bethel, and Woodridge.
Each new installation will be accompanied by rich cultural programming, including exhibits, author talks, lectures, music, and film screenings.
The ultimate goal? A 20-marker trail by 2026, encompassing other potential installations in Loch Sheldrake, Woodbourn, Ellenville, Livingston Manor, and Parksville.
Dual-Sided Signage for a Deeper Understanding
Marker in Monticello
The markers themselves offer a two-sided experience. One side provides a general overview of the Borscht Belt, while the other delves into the specific history of the featured village or town.
Documenting the Past, Inspiring the Future
Photographer and author Marisa Scheinfeld played a pivotal role in capturing the essence of the Borscht Belt history and culture. Over five years, she meticulously documented the area's glory days, as well as the remnants left behind after the decline of hotels, resorts, and bungalows. Her work was featured in a Cornell University Press book titled "The Borscht Belt: Revisiting the Remains of America's Jewish Vacationland" (2016).
Looking towards the future, Scheinfeld says the project hopes its impact will extend far beyond nostalgia alone.
"The response has been immense," she says. "Last year alone, over 500 people of all ages attended our dedications, sharing countless memories and stories." The project also aspires to ignite interest and educate younger generations about the Borscht Belt's legacy.
A Legacy of Entertainment, Community, and More
The Borscht Belt's influence has been immeasurable, says Scheinfeld. "From shaping entertainment, comedy, music, and even elements of design and branding."
She underscores the importance of accuracy and authenticity to solidify the Borscht Belt's legacy for years to come. This documentation, she adds, should not only honor the guests but also pay tribute to the workers and other individuals who helped this era flourish.
Hitting the Road To Explore the Past
Marker Project Logo
Summer provides the perfect opportunity for a historical road trip. Explore the Catskills' natural beauty and visit these villages and towns that share a special chapter in American Jewish history.
The Borscht Belt Historical Marker Project homepage offers a map showcasing the existing markers and the upcoming additions. In the future, the project hopes to secure funding to develop a self-guided audio driving tour to enhance the trail experience.
The project's origins lie in the need for tolerance and empathy, says Scheinfeld, highlighting the connection to the era's anti-Semitism. "Unfortunately, in this climate where antisemitism is soaring, this message feels more important than ever."
Note: The project website offers details on upcoming installations and events.
Previously on Forbes:
